搜索
:,,,,,,,,,:,,,1,2,,,,,4,51999,,,28,,williamAlfordBenja-minLiebmanpaulGewirtzThomaSKelloggJeffreypreseott,1WilliamWade,TheTwilightofNaturalJust:ce?,67IawQuarterlyReview103(1951).2Ridgev.Baldwin1964]Ac40,:,200643SeeGoldbergv.Kelly,397U.5.254(1970).4RiehardPieree,TheDueProeessCOunterrevolutioofthe19905?,96ColumbiaLawReview1973(1996).5,::,19971124:,,,,2004:,,,,6,:,,,,,72080,,:,;8,9,l0),,,2080198634,,,1989,(1996)(2003)2004,H,,2008,67891011,(2004)no20053,:,1934,312(,,);:,1947,215(),,(),(),:,1945,63,,,:,276,1984,80;,1984,914:,1983:,1985;:,198753:,,,;,,,,20:,,;,,,,12520091,,,,,()54,,;,,l2),,,[l3,,,,,,,54,l4j,,,54,,,,,,15,12:,199,247;:,1990,318;:,1993,373;:,1994,257;:,1998,202;:,19961(,,;,),,13,:,24,45;:,25,23;:,25;:,200514,,,,,,:WTO,20014,54;,():,19943,,::,2005415::,1993;:,20012;KevinOBrien&LianjiangLi,s-ingteLoealStat:AJministrativeLitigarioniuralChina,inNeilDiamant,StanleyIubman&Kevin()Brien(eds.),EngagingtheLawinChina:State,SoeietyandPossibltiesforJustice,StanfordUniversityPress,2005.126;[1620,l7j,:???,,,,,,,,,,,l8j,,,,,,,,:,,;,,,;,,,,,,,,,16171819RandallPeerenboom,ChiaLongMdrehToardRuleofLaw,CambridgeUniversityPress,2002,ehap.7(p.298ff.)andehap.9(p.420ff.);BenjarninIiebman,ChinaCourts:RostrietedReform?,ChinaQuarterly(2007).::(19902000),42,2002,ThomasKellogg,CourageousEPlorers?EducationLitigatiandJudioiall,ovatioinChi-na,20HarvardHumanRightsJournal141(2007);:,20073,,(),(1998)10;(),(1999)20;(),(24)61272009l,,,,1989,,,,,;,,,(),,20,,,542158(2528)2005614(),()2972129722,5423()97,33%(53%)(4o%),(26%)(8%),36,12%,,,,,,,1996(),202122,,,(),,,:(1);(2);(3);(4)(),,,,,,,,,,,,,,12823,222319961022,12228,23%;,17571,41%,,227,6%;29,16%32,;13,,,,,,,24,,,,,,,;,,,1991,25j,,,,,,,,,,312,310,:,,(),,,,,,26,232425263132:,,;52,:,3132,,(41),(2001)328199221997212920091(),,9,,:,,,,,27,,,,,,,,,19912000,WTO,WTO,54,,28,,,:29,,,,2090,,,,3,[3l,27{:::,,,(),2002]27,6,241:,,,42,,,,:((,19963)J16,.,1992,,;,,,,,:2,1993,(1999)22[30[3l13,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,,,,,,32:,;(),,,,,,,,:,;,,,,33,,,,,:,,,,,1998,,:,,,:,,,,32:,,,,,,3319994,(1998)14213120091,34):,,,35,,,,,,,??,,36,,,,,,,,37,,;,,,,,,,()(),;,(),,,,:,,?34,(1998)14235(199)64:,,,,;,,,,36,199910,37,,:,,,132,b,,,?:,,,,,6000,,,,,,,,::,,,,,,,,:,;,,,,,,,,,?,38:,,?,,,,,,,,??,,,,,,?,,,,,,38,23,1332009l,,,,;,,,,39,,,,,4,,,,,[4l,,42,,,,,,,,,,2001,,,,,,,,,43,,,,,())::;{:;;43::,19981::,3,2000;18,ThomasKellogg,2001n26;?!,2253,:,2002;:,2003134,,,,,,?,4:,,;,,,:,,,,,,,,,,,,,BBS,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,;,,,;,,,45,,,,,,,,,,,,45,,,3,;(),,673,1999103.1352009l,,[46,,,,47,,48j49j,,50,,())),[5120053,(55),,(56),,(58)46474849505IJ200430,,(),,,,200043;,2000157;,200150,:,19991224;::,2000113;::,2o118,,:(l)19991221::,19991223;43,,(2)20001620:,219;:,2110;::,2000113;:,2000116(3)21204::,200l27;::,20214(4)20007::,))2000723,:,202;::(),20014,2001,200120:,,::::::::43,:,2051()})5,=1547,20081120136,,,52,53,3,,4,54,,,,,,,,,,55,,,[56,,,:,,,,,:,;,,,,,545556:),2005329,(),[200574,teach.ustb.edu.cn/ie_edit/up-loadfile/20070321104230257.doe;(),200575,=51id=4152008xl20242004819:,;,13720091,2004:[57,,;,;,,,58,54,,,,(),(),59,6200412,,,(),,,,,,,,,,,,,:,,?,,:,,,:,,,5960253,(2004)21;,(2004)110,,,,,22:,,,,9:,,,,,138,[6l,,,,,,,4,,5(),,,,,,,,;,(),,,,,1990,63,64,(),:,,,,,,65,6162{::;65,,:,,,,,,,,,,,,,,;,,27n22:,:13,2005;::,20061214,,;,,,;()3,(23)047,,,,,,;,,,1392009166,,6731995,,68,,,,,[69,[70,,,,,,,,,,(),,()[71,,,,72:(),()73,,):{::::70717273,271122,:,,,:,:50(2004),25,271122Google,,453;,209,,15600;,321,895000;,8620027n23,::,200652,htrp://=545,20051120();:,ht://();18,,27126,27121020071128140320053,74j,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,75,()()76,,,;,(3,),[77,,,,8,,79,,,,,(),(),80,,,,,::::;:;{79,(2004)6;258,(2005)3:,,,,(1993,2110)8,,,(),,;,,,(26)191,2006216,=3,((),(24)25,,()()()(),20071127281412009l,,:10,10,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,(),,,,,,,,,142,,,,,,,,,,,,,,(),,,,,,,,,,?,,,,,2001,,,,,81,,,36,,,,,,,82,,,,:83::;;83,(21)39::36,200510:,,,,,R.v.SeeretaryofStateforSoeialServiees,eParteAssoeiationofMetropolitanAuthori-ties[19861WeeklyLawRePtsl,,,,,,14320091,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,:,,,,,(),,,,,,,,;,;,,,,,,,(),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,;,,,,144,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,84j,??,?,,,,,,,,,,,,84::,:3,2000;:,200714520091,,,,,,,,Abstraet:Theeoneeptofdueproeess,inspiredbyAngloAmerieanlaw,hasbeeomewellknewtotheChineselegaleirelesandbeenadoptedinanumberoflegislations.However,whenlaws,regulations,andrulesdonotprovideelearProeessrequirementsforadministrativeorgans,it15stilluneertainwhethertheiudieiaryeanapPlythedueproeessprineipleinreviewingthelegalityofadministrativeaetsornot,giventhattheAdministrativeIJitigationIJaw1989stiPulatesthatanadministrativeaetinviolationofstatutoryproeessshouldbevoid.Bystatistieallyanalyzingthele-galbasisinvokedintheadministrativerulingsinlawreportsand