法律程序主义：论证逻辑和时代际遇[1]

20072D915.18A0257-5833(2007)02-0049-162100972006-12-10[]2005222[]199717200724949200725legitimacy12199912[]200464[]223[],2000322220061[]2001188[]20420072500200725-syntaxsemanticspragmaticsDiscourseTheoryofLawlangueparoleintersubjectivity1234[]34-352003,15[],2001157,200171[],200191[],19892,1994119[]320072511200725TheoryofCommunicativeActionreasonrationalityfacticityvalidityconsensus[],2002138[],20032132[],2002192200725222007253strategicaction1[][][]23[]3437120026[]19872402007253200725goodresultefficacyprocessvalueefficacy20061[]831988[]4492000[]198882R.S.Summers,EvaluatingandImprovingLegalProcess-APleaforProcessvalues,CornellLawReview1974Vol.60,Number1,pp.1-3.[]19965-6[]212[]199754-5562200725442007255[]199754[]200013[]147[]213[]6320072552007256[]2004161[]38-39[]2004151-152[]200544-45[]540-541545805200725620011142007252002279[]2004109[]206[]506507200725772007258sub-politicsdeliberativedemocracy[]2004239240242[]536[]200512007258200725epistemeDiskurs[]546[]226[]41[]200111[]54-55627720072599200726reflectivemodernization14[]141[]74[]686[]2000273[]2002249[]200311920072600200726proceduralistparadigmoflawsubjectivityintersubjectivity[]2001131133[]121MRyan.MarxismandDeconstruction.Baltimore,JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,1984.p39.[]54120072611200726[]51-5346[]200629-30[]4-520072622200726320043[]685[]1993684[]2001131-132[]20015022007263200726discoursetheoryoflawProceduralistTheoryofLaw:TheoreticalLogicandAppropriateCircumstanceofTimesHanDemingAbstract:Proceduralisttheoryoflawassumesanattitudeofovercomingformalistictheoryoflawandsubstantivetheoryoflaw.Proceduralisttheoryoflawhasasystematiclogicofargument.Thislogicisntcompletelyatranscendentalargument,buthasafoundationofcurrentsocialorder.Proceduraltheoryoflawisanappropriatecircumstanceofrisksociety.Chinashouldproposetheproceduralisttheoryoflawandfoundanindividualwayofmodernizationoflaw.Keywords:ProceduralistTheoryofLaw;FormalisticTheoryofLaw;SubstantiveTheoryofLaw;DiscourseTheoryofLaw;RiskSociety2006100[]684[]52004520072644