汉语历史音韵研究中若干问题之我见

20034(61)No.42003ResearchinAncientChineseLanguageSerialNo.61(,100732;,,510275)[]:,;;;,;;;[];;;;[]H111[]A[]1001-5442(2003)04-0013-0702002,2001,(),20024,(),zsu678,,(),,,9,()56,JournalofChineseLinguistics()252(,),,,,1,,,:(1),(2),(3)3,:?20?[1],,,,,,,,20,,,,,,,,,31©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.()(),,,,,,,,,,,,()?,,,,,()[1][2][3],29,30,22,,30(,),,[4],,,()32,31,,19,:,,,,,(),,,,2,,,,,[5],(),,,,[5][p139],,,3,,,,:,:41:[6],18.57%[4],©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.),,,,,,,:,,[12]!,,,,,,,([13],[14],[15]),,20,,,,,,,,:,:VVkV—,ViVtVn,VpVm(V)[9][p128],,,,,,,:,,,,,,,(,),,,,,,,;,(),,20,(),,,,,,,,71:::(:)(:)[2][p4],aaia,,2i2t2n,a,,([16][5]),,,©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.:,,,,21,20,20,,,,,,,,8,,,::,,;,,,;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,[17]!,,:,,,,,,,,,,,9,;,;,,();(),,,,,,,,,10,,:,;,,81:©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.():[1].[A].[C].:,1989.[2].[M].:,1980.[3].[M].:,1985.[4].[A].()[C].:,1980.[5].[M].:,1963.[6].[A].1[C].:,1984.[7].[A].(13)[C].:,1984.[8].[M].,1947.[9].[M].:,2000.[10].[J].,1987,(4).[11].[J].,2003,(2).[12].[A]..()[M].:,1981.[13].[M].:,1991.[14].[A].(7)[C].:,1995.[15].[M].:,2001.[16].[M].:,1957.[17].[J].,2000,(4).SomeIssuesonChineseHistoricalPhonologyMAIYun(InstituteofLinguistics,ChineseAcademyofSocialSciences,Beijing100732,China)(ChineseDepartment,SunYat-senUniversity,Guangzhou510275,China)Abstract:ThispaperraisessomeviewsonthepapersbyTsu2LinMei()andGuoXi2liang().ItiswrongforMeitosaythatWangLis()doesnotbelongtothemaintrendoftheresearchonoldChinesephonology.ItsadefectthatWangresearchedtheoldChineseinitialswithoutXiesheng().OughttoadvocatetheresearchmethodofthecombinationofSino-TibtiancomparativelinguisticsandoldChinesephonology.ItsnecessarytodistinguishandanalyseGuoscriticismtoPanWu2yun().Oughttopromotetheopenacademicconceptanddaretobreakthroughthetradition.Oughttounder2standtherelationbetweencreativeandcautiousattitudesintheacademicstudies.Oughttopurifytheairofacademiccriticism.KeyWords:maintrend;systemofXiesheng();Sino-Tibtiancomparativeresearch;breakthroughthetradition;creativeattitude[](1953-),,,,[:]91:©1994-2008ChinaAcademicJournalElectronicPublishingHouse.Allrightsreserved.