Peer-Review-Checklist

PeerReviewChecklistDraftwrittenbyFeedbackprovidedbyDate:Composition:Yourpurposeinansweringthesequestionsistoprovideanhonest&helpfulresponsetoyourpeer’sdraft.Youshouldalsosuggestwaystomakehis/herwritingbetter.Beforebeginningyourreview,besuretoreadthecompositioncarefully.Afterthat,respondtothefollowingquestions.BESPECIFIC.BECONSTRUCTIVE.Content1.Istheproblemdefinedclearlyandexplainedadequatelyintermsoftheseriousness,causes,andeffects?Yes___No___（说明：)2.Isthesolutiondescribedadequately?Yes___No___（说明：）3.Arethegoalsofthesolutionandthestepsforimplementationexplainedclearly?Yes___No__（说明：)4.Is(are)thereanysupportingidea(s)irrelevantorillogicaltothetopic?Yes___No___•Ifyes,pointit/themoutandexplainyourreasons.说明：5.Doesthewriterconsiderthealternativesolutionsand/orobjectionstotheproposal?Yes___No___（说明：)Organization6.Canthebeginningcatchthereader’sattention?Yes___No___（说明：）7.Isthereacleartransitionalsignalbetweenpresentationoftheproblemandpresentationofthesolution?Yes___No___（说明：)8.Arethereclearandlogicallinksbetweendiscussionoftheproblem,thesolution,andalternativesolutions?Yes___No___（说明：）9.Istheconclusionnaturalandconvincing?Yes___No___•Ifno,canyouexplainandgivesomesuggestions?（说明：）Language10.Doesthewriterusedifferenttypesofsentences?Yes___No___（说明：）11.Doesthewriteruseinteresting/powerfulwords/phrasestocreatestyle?Yes___No___（说明：）12.Arethereproblemswithspelling,grammar,punctuation?Yes___No___•Ifyes,pleaseunderlinetheproblematicpartsandgiveyourownsuggestion.（说明：）Responsetothewriter’squestion:__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________Additionalcomments:__________________________________________________________________