台湾公司治理结构(1)

1CorporateGovernanceBarclayHolderness1989BergolfPerotti1994Charkham1994Hansmann1996EnronArthurAndersenAA1200210NSC892412212003190Pettigrew19929080Blair1995ownershipcontrolControlMechanismshareholders2modernindustrialcorporationAdamSmith1937CoaseR.HEconomic3ThecontractualtheoryofthefirmAgencytheoryfirmsizeAlchianandDemesetz1972freeriding22AlchianandDemesetz19724residualclaimantrightteamproductionJensenandMeckling19763agencyproblem35AlfredD.ChandlerJr.1977modernindustrialcorporationChandler19977……..ibid86managerialcapitalism2001AdolfA.BerleandGardinerC.Meansdispersion200managementcontrol44BerleandMeans1controlthroughcompleteownership7………BerleandMeans1932114115BerleandMeans19325802majoritycontrol503controlthroughlegaldevice20504minoritycontrol505managementcontrol206523214419325Jensen8Blair1995hostiletakeoveracquisition6junkbondDertouzosLesterandSolow1989Meckling19763606RobinMarris1964OliverWilliamson1964bottomlineJensenandRuback1983ScanlonTriftsandPettway1989RavenscraftandScherer19877GMGMGM50GM919808MargaretM.Blair19951CEOMarkJ.Roe1994GMGMbluechipGMGMGM198045199035GM1988GM19901991Drucker2000Useem1998819821995321431Useem1998102001三、公司治理結構的同形異種（Isomorphic）agentcoastAlchian19651968AlchianandKessel1962Demsetz1967AlchianandDemsetz1972MonsenandDowns1965SilverandAuster1969JensenandMeckling197611socialconstructingeconomicmodelsocialrealityMarkJ.RolStrongMangersWeakOwnersThePoliticalRootsofAmericanCorporateFinance1995theeconomicsoforganizationRoe19958firmsfinanciersRoe1995xPreface12Ibid21palacerevolutionIbid21selfisheconomicinterestsideologythenation’sinstitutioncorporatefinancialstructuredeductiveeconomicsmultiplehistoricalforcespopulismfederalismIbid4913kaleidoscopeRoe1995Ibid151flatterRoe1995736HausbankKulber1991Kallfass19881956TheBankIIoldingCompanyActTheGlassSteagallAct1940TheInvestmentCompanyAct1934TheSecuritiesExchangeAct14votingblock5221010030510DaimlerBenzGM78.39%GM13.93%Roe1995supervisoryboard996149boardofmanagementVorstandsupervisoryboardAufsichtstrat15Roe199519985196719935zaibutsu10MiyashitaandRussel1994horizontalkeiretsuMichaelL.Gerlach1992AllianceCapitalismshachokai10MiyashitaandRussel1994Gerlach19921619828550Sheard19892020Cable1985Jokn17CableCable19851949StephenProwse198019847611331991AokiMasahiko1984inrealityconfiguration18.OrruBiggartHamilton199719851973198319831985198819921993199419941994199819981999------199933533619……….BerleandMeans193252011991200155%40%FIBV199942.8%30.0%28%8.1%37%13.7%Ljubijana30.0%FIBV25%58.0%48.2%20011991200160211119901985761219851311312199013151.51017.50.7550.5pp5575581994221989101030405myth199920002314639000757000000.84%22152280313.64%50959.10%5014.55%215010201412151999181937241030174229.821941011110.59202225throughtheirstockinterestworkingcontrolproxies261994271.19839163842.198519963.19924.19915.19946.19887.19848126368.19949.198310.1989””11.1990pp8595.12.199413.2001200114.1999---mook1----2815.199715516.2001468465317.2000()()28,291-701-491.Alchian,A.A,1965,Thebasisofsomerecentadvanceinthetheoryofmanagementofthefirm,JournalofIndustrialEconomics,Nov.,30-44.2.Alchian,A.A.andH.Demsetz,1972,Production,informationcosts,andeconomicorganization,AmericanEconomicReviewLXII,no.5:777-795.3.Alchian,A.A,andR.A.Kessel,1962,Competition,monopolyandthepursuitofpecuniarygain,in:AspectsofLaboreconomics(NationalBureauofEconomicsResearch,Princeton,NJ).4.BarclayMichaelandCliffordHolderness1989PrivateBenefitsfromControlofPublicCorporationJournalofFinancialEconomics2537155.BerglofErikeandEnroicoPerotti1994TheGovernanceStructureoftheJapaneseFinancialKerietsuJournalofFinancialEconomics36259284.6.BerleA.A.andMeansG.C.1932TheModernCorporationandPrivateProperty.NewYorkMacmillan.7.BlairMargaretM.,1995,OwnershipandControl:RethinkingCorporateGovernancefortheTwenty-firstCentury.Washington,D.C.:TheBrookingsInstitution.8.CableJohn,1985,CapitalMarketInformationandIndustrialperformance:TheRoleofWestGermanBank,95Econ.J.118-119.9.ChandlerAlfredD.Jr.1961StrategyandStructure.CambridgeMITPress.----1977TheVisibleHandTheManagerialRevolutioninAmericanBusiness.HarvardUniversityPress.10.Coase,R.H.,1988.TheFirm,theMarket,andtheLaw,Chicago,Illinois,USA.11.CharkhamJonathan1994KeepingGoodCompanyAStudyoftheBoardofDirectorsandtheCEO.ManagementInternationalReview,25:65-70.12.Demsetz,H.,1967,Towardatheoryofpropertyrights,AmericanEconomicReviewLVII,May,347-359.13.Dertouzos,Michael,RichardK.Lester,andRobertSolow,des,1989,MadeinAmerica:RegainingtheProductiveEdge.MITPress.14.DruckerPeterF.,2000,(ConceptofTheCorporation),:.15.EisenbergM.A.1969TheLegalrolesofshareholderandmanagementin29moderncorporatedecisionmakingCaliforniaLawReview571.16.FitchR.1972SweezyandcorporatefetishismSocialistRevolution17.GoldmithR.W.andParmeleeR.C.1940TheDistributionofOwnershipinthe200LargestNonfinancialCorporations.MonographsoftheTemporaryNationalEconomicCommitteeNumber29.WashingtonGovernmentPrintingOfficefortheUSSenate.18.GordonR.A.1945BusinessLeadershipinLargeCorporations.WashingtonBrookingsInstitution..19.Gerlach,Michael,1992,AllianceCapitalism:TheSocialOrg