Theeconomyortheenvironmentmustwechoose?OnApril20,2010GulfofMexicoOilSpilled.OnMarch11,2011Fukushimanuclearplantexploded.OnJune4,2011BohaiSeaoilspilled.OnAugust27,2011massfishdiedinGutian,FujianProvince.OnSeptember12,2011aFrancenuclearplantexploded.April20,2010MexicoMarch11,2011JapanJune4,2011ChinaAugust27,2011ChinaSeptember12,2011Francewhen&where......?Humanbeingeconomyenvironmentmustwechoose?economyenvironmentDebateadebate---acontesttwoormorespeakerstrytopersuadeoneanotherpropositionoppositionchairpersonargument(论点)supportingdetailsToday’shostJamesLongDebaters:MsLinShuiqing:aspokeswomanfromtheGreenSocietyMrQianLiwei:abusinessdevelopmentconsultantLinShuiqingPart1MsLin’sspeechFastreadingByhowmanytimeshastheworld'spopulationincreasedsince1800?MsLin’sspeech1.Whatistheresultofchemicalwaste?2.Whatishappeningtolargenumbersoffish?3.WhatsuggestionsdoesMsLingiveusattheendofherspeech?DetailedreadingConclusionMsLin’sargument:Humanbeingsshouldn’tdeveloptheeconomyattheexpenseof(以…为代价)theenvironment.environmentalistQianLiweiWhatisyourfirstimpressionofbusinessmen?Part2MrQian’sspeechMrQian’sargument:Ahealthyenvironmentanddevelopmentshouldbepossibleatthesametime.MrQian’ssupportingdetails:control/repairbedeeplyconcernedaboutpeoplemoreimportantrecycledmaterials/rawbetterlawshigherprice/taxes×Similarity:Differences:Newideas:recyclingfactoriesproductionbetterlawshigherprice/taxescomparisonPost-readingRetell(复述)twodebatersspeechesandexpressyourownideasaswell.Ms.LinShuiqing:Humanbeingsshouldnotdeveloptheeconomyattheexpenseof(以…为代价)theenvironment.Firstly,_________________________.Secondly,_______________________.●●●Tosumup,weshould_______________.Mr.QianLiwei:Ahealthyenvironmentanddevelopmentshouldbepossibleatthesametime.Firstly,_________________________.Secondly,_______________________.●●●Tosumup,weshould_______________.Discussion:Howcanweachieveabalancebetweentheeconomyandtheenvironment?1.Wecouldeducatepeopletorespectandprotecttheenvironment.2.Wecouldurgefactoriesthatproducelargeamountsofwastetobuildasystemtopurifythewasteandminimizethedamagetotheenvironment.3.Wecouldurgethegovernmenttopassstricterlawstoprotecttheenvironment.4.Wecouldproducestrictlawstopreservetheenvironment.5.Wecouldcreateasystemtodealwiththewasteandrubbishscientifically.Anationdestroyingitsenvironmentdestroysitself.------F.D.RooseveltWriteanarticleaboutenvironmentoreconomy.Homework