20111235ChinJEvidBasedCardiovascMedDecember2011Vol.3No.5··GRADEprofilerR4A1674-4055201105-0390-031。。GRADE、GradesofRecommendationsAssessmentDevelopmentandEval-uationGRADE2004--GRADE2-3。、、GRADE、GRADEproGRADEprofilersoft-ware43.6。GRADEpro3.6。1GRADEproGRADEpro3.6http//ims.cochrane.org/revman/oth-er-resources/gradepro/download。“C\ProgramFiles\GRADEprofiler”。。GRADEpro2.0Microsoft.NETFrameworkversion2.0。2GRADEproGRADEpro。。GRADE。ProfilestreeEdit。。3GRADEproGRADEpro4CochraneCDSRtheSummaryofFindingstableSoFGRADEGRADEevidenceprofileEPOverviewofReviewstableOoR。GRADEGRADEproCochrane。、、GRADEpro2010201001720112011QD012011QD05442000E-maillwd35@163.comdoi10.3969/j.issn.1674-4055.2011.05.023。SoF、EPOoR/MetaSR/MAGRADE。GRADEproGRADEproSoFRevMan5RevMan5.1TablesSummaryoffindingstables。4GRADEpro《Meta》“T”4GRADEpro3.6。GRADEpro3.6“help”。4.1GRADEGradedatafileGRADEpro3.6“File”“New”“T”“”“.grd”GRADE。4.2“ProfileGroupname”SR/MA“T”“Addprofile”“Evi-denceprofile”“Profileinformation”。4.3SR/MASR/MA“Evidenceprofile”“Profileinformation”。“Evidenceprofile”“Format”“shouldinterventionvscompari-sionbeusedforhealthproblem”“Interven-tion、Comparsion、HealthproblemSetting”4“Format”“Inter-ventionSetting”2。SR/MA“Question”“SoFtitle”。“Timeframe”2007~2010。“Profileinformation”“Bibliography”SR/MA“T”“Profileauthors”“CreatedonLastmajorupdate”。①“SoFtitle”“Edit”。“Question”②“Setting”“”“Otherconsiderations”“、、”。4.44.3“Addoutcome”。“Nameofoutcome”“Shortname”“Importance”·093·20111235ChinJEvidBasedCardiovascMedDecember2011Vol.3No.55“IMPORTANCE”“Assessed/measuredwith”“”“Noofstud-ies”8“Studydesign”“Studydesign”randomisedtrails“Lengthoffollow-up”range38.3to98.7、“oth-er”min。3①1~3NOTIMPORTANT②4~6IMPORTANT③7~9CRITICAL。SR/MA。4.5。“Studyde-sign”randomisedstudies。“Downgradequalityofevi-dence”“Upgradequalityofevidence”“Footnote”“no”。GRADE1。①“Upgradequalityofevidence”“Publicationbias”“Otherconsid-erations”②GRADEpro3.6“Publicationbias”GRADEpro3.2“12”“1”。“no”“”“Qualityofevidence”“HIGH”“”“MORDERATE”“Otherconsiderations”“reportingbias”“Downgradequalityofevidence”“HIGH→MORDERATE→LOW”“Up-gradequalityofevidence”“LOW→MORDERATE→HIGH”。1GRADE4.6“GotoSummaryofFindings”。“Outcome”“”。“dichoto-mouscontinuous”continuous“pooled”pooled“totalnumberofpar-ticipants”“Intervention”470“Control”521“Interven-tionControl”“Finalvalues/changescoresincontrols”range38.3to98.7“Units”min“EstimateoftheEffect”SMD“of”SMD1.07“95%CI”SMD95%from0.19to1.94“Rangeofpossiblescores”0to4“Betterindicatedby”higher。“pooled”“notmeasured”“notreported”4.5。4.7EP、SoFOoR“View”。“PerviewSoFtable”。continuousdichotomous。4.84.8.1“Add”“Outcome”“”“Addoutcome”“Newoutcome”“”。4.4。4.8.24.4~4.7。“Newoutcome”“Nameofoutcome”“”。“GotoSummaryofFindings”“dichoto-mous”%。4.9SoF“PerviewSoFtable”。SoF“Selectformat”“GRADEevidenceprof”EP。“Options”“Exporttabletemplate”“No.ofrows”。4.10SoFSoF、EPOoR3。“SaveHTMLfile”EPHTML“SaveasImage”“Imageformat”“Quality”“ExporttoWordDocument”word。“SaveasImage”SoF、EPOoR“jpeg”4.1。5GRADEproRevMan·193·20111235ChinJEvidBasedCardiovascMedDecember2011Vol.3No.545GRADEpro3.6RevMan5.1。。5.1GRADEpro3.6RevManGRADEpro3.6“File”“Importfrom”“ReviewManagerfile”T.rm5“”“T.rm5”。“”“”4.4“NameofoutcomeNoofstudies”4.4。“GotoSummaryofFindings”4.5。“Finalvalues/changescoresincontrols、Units、Rangeofpossiblescores”3。4.7、4、94.10。“”4.8“GotoSummaryofFind-ings”。5.2RevMan5.1SoF44.7“File”“Exportas”“ReviewManagerSoF”“”“T”“”“T.SoF”。“T.rm5”RevMan5.1“Tables”“SummaryofFindingstables”“AddSummaryofFindingsTable”1。“NewSummaryofFindingsTableWizard”“Importtheta-blefromafliecreatedinGRADEprofiler”“CreatethetableusingRevMan'stableeditor”3RevMan5SoF“Next”“Open”GRADEpro3.6“T.SoF”2“Open”“Finsh”SoFRev-Man5.13。1236GRADE。GRADE6。GRADEGRADEpro。GRADEGRADEproSR/MA。、GRADEGRADEGRADE。GRADEpro。GRADEpro3.6、3。GRADEpro3.2GRADEpro3.6v3.6、GRADE。GRADEproGRADEGRADEGRADEpro、。1WorldreportonknowledgeforbetterhealthstrengtheninghealthsystemsR.GenevaWorldHealthOrganization2004.2AtkinsDBestDBrissPAetal.GradingqualityofevidenceandstrengthofrecommendationsJ.BMJ200432874541490-1494.3.GRADEJ.2011119985-990.4GRADEpro.Computerprogram.Version3.2forWindows.JanBrozekAndrewOxmanHolgerSchünemann2008.5.MetaJ.201111101172-1183.6GuyattGHOxmanADVistGEetal.GRADEanemergingcon-sensusonratingqualityofevidenceandstrengthofrecommenda-tionsJ.BMJ20083367650924-926.2011-09-052011-10-21·293·